Trial Day 18 · Court in 3 Minutes

Defense Rests Case After Dr. Resnick Cross-Examination; State Expert Dr. Mack Testifies Clancy Retained Criminal Responsibility

Day 18 concluded the testimony of defense expert Dr. Phillip Resnick and opened the state's rebuttal case with expert psychiatrist Dr. Avram Mack. Dr. Resnick reiterated his opinion that Lindsay Clancy suffered from Bipolar II and postpartum psychosis, rendering her unable to conform her conduct to the law. On cross-examination, prosecutor Jennifer Sprague questioned him regarding indicators of malingering, post-incident mental stability, and Clancy's non-disclosure of harm impulses to medical providers. After the defense rested, the state called Dr. Mack, who diagnosed Clancy with a major depressive episode rather than bipolar disorder or psychosis. Dr. Mack concluded Clancy retained criminal responsibility, citing her methodical execution, daily functioning, and awareness of wrongfulness.

Read Full Transcript All Daily Recaps

The Hot Points

What mattered today

Defense expert Dr. Phillip Resnick testified Clancy suffered from Bipolar II with severe depression and postpartum psychosis on January 24, 2023, rendering her unable to conform her conduct to the law due to command hallucinations.

Source: REV_CLANCY_DAY_18_629a32ee_SEG_0188, REV_CLANCY_DAY_18_629a32ee_SEG_0194, REV_CLANCY_DAY_18_629a32ee_SEG_0203

Prosecution cross-examination highlighted that Clancy repeatedly denied homicidal thoughts to her healthcare providers and that Tewksbury Hospital records documented her as clinically stable without observable psychosis.

Source: REV_CLANCY_DAY_18_629a32ee_SEG_0283, REV_CLANCY_DAY_18_629a32ee_SEG_0316

The defense officially rested its case following the conclusion of Dr. Resnick's testimony.

Source: REV_CLANCY_DAY_18_629a32ee_SEG_0377

Prosecution called expert psychiatrist Dr. Avram Mack, who diagnosed Clancy with a major depressive episode rather than bipolar disorder, finding no evidence of mania, hypomania, or active psychosis leading up to the events.

Source: REV_CLANCY_DAY_18_629a32ee_SEG_0719, REV_CLANCY_DAY_18_629a32ee_SEG_0731, REV_CLANCY_DAY_18_629a32ee_SEG_0776

Dr. Mack concluded Clancy retained criminal responsibility, pointing to her methodical actions, intact daily routine on January 24, and awareness that harming her children was wrong.

Source: REV_CLANCY_DAY_18_629a32ee_SEG_0976, REV_CLANCY_DAY_18_629a32ee_SEG_0982, REV_CLANCY_DAY_18_629a32ee_SEG_1012

Defense cross-examination of Dr. Mack emphasized Clancy's complex medication history and highlighted that she was evaluated in a psychiatric facility while under continuous 24-hour observation.

Source: REV_CLANCY_DAY_18_629a32ee_SEG_0653, REV_CLANCY_DAY_18_629a32ee_SEG_1041

Prosecution

Points emphasized

Prosecutor Sprague elicited from Dr. Resnick that command auditory hallucinations are easily fabricated and that individuals experiencing genuine command hallucinations do not always obey dangerous orders.

Admitted medical records from Tewksbury Hospital indicated Clancy was clinically stable with intact reality testing and showed no observable cognitive or behavioral instability since admission.

Dr. Mack testified Clancy retained substantial capacity to appreciate the wrongfulness of her conduct, citing her pre-incident statements reflecting fear that her children would be taken away if anyone knew her thoughts.

Dr. Mack concluded Clancy maintained the capacity to conform her conduct, pointing to her organized execution of the killings, multi-step suicide attempt, and normal daily activities like driving and visiting a pharmacy.

Defense

Points emphasized

Dr. Resnick opined Clancy was frankly psychotic on January 24, 2023, suffering from command hallucinations and delusions of influence that deprived her of the ability to conform her conduct to the requirements of the law.

Dr. Resnick noted MMPI psychological testing administered by prosecution experts showed no evidence that Clancy was faking or exaggerating psychiatric symptoms.

Defense cross-examination established that Clancy was prescribed multiple psychiatric medications leading up to January 2023, including sertraline, Prozac, sleep aids, and Seroquel.

Defense cross-examination highlighted that Dr. Mack evaluated Clancy in a psychiatric hospital setting where she remained under continuous 24-hour observation.

Worth Knowing

Other developments from court

Dr. Avram Mack testified that under DSM guidelines, the peripartum onset specifier applies to mood episodes starting within four weeks of delivery, whereas Clancy's distress began approximately four months postpartum.

Dr. Mack testified that running a road race and decluttering a home post-childbirth do not in and of themselves constitute evidence of a manic or hypomanic episode.

Dr. Mack explained that postpartum psychosis is a proposed clinical syndrome that is not currently recognized as an independent diagnostic category in the DSM.

Dr. Resnick acknowledged on cross-examination that he has previously taught courses to forensic evaluators regarding how to testify believable and handle questioning in court.